Chinese Court Recognizes English Court Commercial Judgments for the First Time
Introduction: Recently, Hai Tong & Partners, acting for a Norwegian shipowner, applied to Shanghai Maritime Court for recognition of the judgments and orders of English courts and was ruled in favor. This is a case in which Chinese court for the first time recognized commercial judgment of English court in accordance with the principle of reciprocity. This case reverses the long-standing misunderstanding that the reciprocal relationship is interpreted restrictively as ‘reciprocal on fact’ in Chinese judicial practice, and is the first case in which Chinese court recognizes commercial judgments of English courts on the basis of the principle of “reciprocal on law”. This case is also the first case for trial of the recognition and enforcement of foreign court judgments with reference to the Memorandum of the National Courts' Symposium on Trials for Commercial and Maritime Cases Involving Foreign Elements (hereinafter as “the Memo”). Basic opinions put forward by Hai Tong in this case were fully reflected in Part 9 of the Memo concerning “Trial of Cases Concerning Application for Recognition and Enforcement of Judgments of Foreign Courts”. Given the global influence of English courts in commercial disputes resolution, the ruling of Chinese court in this case is of milestone significance, which shows that with the tremendous development of China in economic field, China will be more open and inclusive in the field of foreign-related commercial trial and judicial assistance.
2022-03-24